Imagine the worship leader who is having a fantastic worship service all by himself.
The band is cooking. The electric guitar player has finally discovered delay pedals! The drummer is building like he’s scoring a Marvel trailer. The worship leader has his eyes closed and he’s soaring into bridge number seven as if the whole room is about to erupt.
Unfortunately, the whole room is not about to erupt.
The whole room is staring at him.
Why? Because he isn’t leading the congregation in front of him. He’s leading the congregation in his head.
This imaginary congregation is a wonderful bunch. They bought the new worship album the day it dropped. They know the alternate bridge from the live version. They can sing a high E before coffee. They love spontaneous moments and fog machines.
Then Sunday morning arrives and the real congregation walks in.
Worship Leaders Must Know the Real People in the Room
The real congregation is the older saint who has sung hymns for fifty years. The real congregation is the widower sitting by himself for the first time. The real congregation is the single mom who barely made it without a parking-lot meltdown. The real congregation is the teenager pretending not to listen. The real congregation is the unchurched visitor who has no idea what’s going on.
And these are the people God has given you.
Not the conference crowd. Not the YouTube crowd. Not the congregation at Famous Megachurch where everyone appears to be twenty-eight, attractive and suspiciously well-lit. Your congregation.
What the Purple Cow Philosophy Means for Worship Ministry
Seth Godin’s Purple Cow idea is usually summarized as “be remarkable.” Worship leaders, being musicians, often translate that into “be weird enough to get noticed.” So we chase the newest sound, the edgiest intro, the drum loop.
But in ministry, remarkable is not always radical. Sometimes remarkable is simply paying attention.
Choose Worship Songs That Fit Your Congregation’s Musical Language
As I wrote many years ago, I once taught a class at a worship conference and a guy told me his church simply wasn’t responding. He was doing all the latest worship songs, exactly like the recordings, and trying to be current and relevant.
So I asked him what style of music his congregation actually liked.
“Bluegrass,” he said.
You could almost see the light go on in his head!
His problem wasn’t the songs, it was the style. He had taken arena worship songs and dropped them, untouched, into a room full of people whose musical heart language involved acoustic guitars, fiddles and somebody named Earl.
I hope he went home and started doing Passion songs with a banjo!
Being Musically Current Does Not Always Mean Being Pastorally Wise
Worship leaders forget that we are ahead of the musical curve. We listen to worship music in the car, at the gym. By the time a new song reaches the normal church member, we’re already tired of it.
Your congregation is not where you are musically. They may not know the song. They may not understand the style. They may not be able to sing the key. The band may be having the time of their lives while the congregation quietly watches the show.
Good Worship Leadership Means Shepherding at the Congregation’s Pace
This does not mean you should let the crankiest person in the church dictate your set list. A shepherd leads sheep; he doesn’t hand them a clipboard and ask them to design the pasture. Your church may need new songs. Older congregations need fresh truth. Younger congregations need old hymns.
But a shepherd also knows the pace of the sheep.
When you move too far ahead, you’re not guiding the group anymore; you’ve simply left them behind.
Watch and Listen to Your Congregation During Worship
So here’s a terrifying idea: watch your congregation.
Are they singing or standing there, spectating? Are the men singing, or have you placed every song in a key only dolphins and tenors can enjoy? Are visitors understanding the lyrics, or are you tossing around insider phrases like everyone received a secret church glossary at the door? Are you introducing so many new songs that your people never own one?
Listen for the congregation. They will tell you what works long before they fill out a survey. They tell you when they roar out an old hymn, when a song falls flat, when a key is too high and when the simple acoustic version connects better than your twelve-layer arrangement.
(I’ll never forget visiting a famous megachurch, passionately performing the latest worship hits. The congregation watched in spectator mode. But then, inexplicably, they accidently dropped a hymn into the set and the congregation literally roared it out with gusto. So sad.)
Plan Worship Services for the Actual People in Your Church
💡What would happen if you planned worship for the actual people in your church this week?
You might repeat a song instead of adding another new one. You might lower a key. You might simplify the arrangement. You might use a hymn. You might choose clearer Gospel language. You might turn the wall of sound into something people can actually sing through.
You might even turn Passion into bluegrass.
Bottom Line: The Purple Cow Worship Leader Notices the Congregation
The Purple Cow philosophy is not permission to be weird for the sake of being weird, current for the sake of being current or “remarkable” in a way that only impresses other worship leaders. In worship ministry, the truly remarkable thing may be far less glamorous: noticing your people.
Stop leading the imaginary congregation in your head. Start shepherding the actual congregation God has placed in front of you. If your people sing better when you lower the key, lower the key. If they connect with a hymn, use the hymn. If the modern song works better with a banjo than a synth pad, grab the banjo.
Your Purple Cow may not be fog, loops, lights or the newest bridge from the latest live album. Your Purple Cow may simply be a room full of normal people actually singing.
And that, believe it or not in this day and age, would be pretty remarkable.
Loading ...