Click Track Philosophy

Are you ready to take the next step in the quality of your worship music? I’ve seen firsthand how a click track can take an average group of amateurs and turn them into something special.

Any time changes are tried in ministry, even for the better, you’ll be met with attitudes. Here are some things to expect:

Drummers: You’ll probably get the most resistance from the drummer. You’ll hear things like “I never play with a click because it destroys the feel” (which being interpreted is “I have no internal rhythm and a click track will make that glaringly obvious.”)

Pianists: Classically trained church pianists are notorious for having zero rhythm. I was classically trained and, out of college, my rocker friends would laugh at me when I tried to play with them – I simply could not keep in time with the drummer.

As pianists we’re taught not to follow a steady rhythm (except using a metronome when practicing a Bach fugue.) One of the first things I did when I graduated was to buy a drum machine to knock myself out of the classical mentality (anyone remember the Alesis HR-16? It’s in the picture at the top of this post.) I’d play along with a drum pattern, get lost in myself and be off the beat within 10 seconds. But after time I learned to lock in.

[quote_left]And that’s what any drummer or pianist must do to learn to play with a click: practice. Get used to hearing that sound boring into your brain and start obeying it.[/quote_left] And that’s what any drummer or pianist must do to learn to play with a click: practice. Get used to hearing that sound boring into your brain and start obeying it. And once you do amazing things can happen: the band’s groove will improve, you can sync to video and add drum loops and other sweetening.

Quality means balance. I talked in a recent article about my experience at Lifechurch where the entire set was programmed to a strict click. This either/or mentality is rampant in churches – you’ll either see only programmed perfection or a wandering free for all. Why not have both: a mature music ministry should have moments of tight rocking as well as tender moments where the Spirit leads.

I got into a debate over this when planning our Christmas Eve service. A member of our team insisted the entire service be on a click. But one of worship leader Steve Smith’s strengths is facilitating that moment of ministry when the programmed praise set settles down, he talks a bit then leads into a worship ballad – and those moments can’t be programmed.

Plan a hole or two in your set where the pianist/keyboardist can exercise his or her talents by noodling under a prayer then flowing into a piano worship ballad without the click. This gives your worship experience a chance to breathe. If you make room to let the Spirit move, maybe He will.

Break Free From Praise Band Boredom

Try freshening up the recorded versions of popular praise songs with these tips from worship leader Rob Rash:

Leading worship is a great and wonderful responsibility. We have to maintain creativity with song and structural integrity. So how do you balance creativity over being a worship cover band?

It’s a fine line and there are many factors to consider. You have to rely on your band. You have to spend valuable time working the song. You have to break free from ‘the way we have always done it.’ And it has to work!

Otherwise, you’ll just be another worship cover band.

So how do break free from the worship machine mediocrity? Here are 6 suggestions to get you started…

Acoustic or Piano Run-through – Work through the song with only an acoustic guitar or piano. There is nothing more humbling or eye opening than being this vulnerable. It may help you re-invent some classics.

Change the Arrangement – Break free from the ‘usual’ way you do the song. Start with the chorus rather than the verse. Drop that extra pre chorus. Just try another arrangement.

Ask Other Worship Pastors/Musicians – This may or may not seem obvious… but ask other worship pastors or musicians how they do the song. Use Twitter, Facebook, and local Network’s to find some creative versions of your worship tunes.

Play an Acoustic Set – Sometimes simplicity is a beautiful thing. Try planning and playing an acoustic set for worship but use your whole band, don’t just use an acoustic guitar. Using drums, keyboard, bass, electric, and acoustic will force you to be creative.

Add Other Instruments – By adding another instrument, say a banjo or accordion, you can really change the sound and textures of the song. This requires more versatility in your band, but certainly will help you be creative.

Rely on Your Band – Too many times we neglect the valuable opinions and musical pedigree of our teams. They have a lot to offer, however, if they are never given the opportunity you’ll miss a great resource!

Leading worship means we rely on the creativity and divine inspiration of others for worship songs. But it doesn’t require us to be poor and uninspired cover bands. Creativity abounds and you will only be as creative as you want to be. Don’t settle… pursue creative ways to worship.

What do find is the hardest part in being creative in worship?

What are some other ways we can be creative in our worship bands?

In-Ear Monitoring Systems for Worship

When I started with click tracks and loops many years ago I began with a super simple (and primitive) setup. I’d create a drum loop in my software (Stylus), burn a CD and play it from a portable CD player on my keyboard. The drum loop would be fed mainly to the drummer through monitors so he could keep with it as we had no budget for in-ears. The soundman would mix the loop into the live sound.

Next I graduated to using a laptop at my keyboard but still we used regular monitors. This was in a church of about 300.

As I’ve played in mega churches I’ve seen the other side of things – using in-ear monitoring systems. The church typically purchases glorified ear buds that fit securely in your ear – you don’t hear anything but the mix, no outside noise. These ear buds are far more advanced and expensive than what you get with your iPod and can cost hundreds of dollars depending on fidelity. I see lots of Westones in these churches.

LoopsInWorship.com has a good rundown on what equipment to use – take a look at their tutorial. The main contenders are Aviom and Hear Backs. I have a friend who plays at a smaller church who bought the Hear Backs since they’re less expensive and he hates them. He says they’re always running out of channels.

Top 10 CCLI for week ending 07-23-11

Sign up for the free weekly WorshipIdeas newsletter and have the top 25 songs delivered to your inbox every week.

1 Mighty To Save
Ben Fielding, Reuben Morgan

2 How Great Is Our God
Chris Tomlin, Jesse Reeves, Ed Cash

3 Blessed Be Your Name
Beth Redman, Matt Redman

4 Everlasting God
Brenton Brown, Ken Riley

5 Revelation Song
Jennie Lee Riddle

6 Here I Am To Worship
Tim Hughes

7 Amazing Grace (My Chains Are Gone)
Chris Tomlin, Louie Giglio, John Newton

8 Open The Eyes Of My Heart
Paul Baloche

9 Your Grace Is Enough
Matt Maher

10 Jesus Messiah
Chris Tomlin, Daniel Carson, Jesse Reeves, Ed Cash

Church Trip: LifeChurch in Oklahoma City

Doomsday evangelist Jack Van Impe has got my 79 year old mother all worked up. He’s been ranting that contemporary churches like Saddleback are apostate because they don’t display the cross!

Dr. Van Impe would be pleased with Lifechurch – they have a ginormous cross sitting right in the middle of their parking lot. And I mean ginormous – it’s a few stories tall and you can see it from the highway (as I approached the church I actually wondered if my GPS was off as it seemed more in line with Orlando’s Holy Land Experience than a high tech ministry, but good for them for being daring.)

Lifechurch is starting their yearly “At the Movies” sermon series where they analyze popular films from a Biblical perspective. Nearly every inch of the church, inside and out, is very elaborately, cleverly and painstakingly decorated in a “Kung Foo Panda” theme (see the Flicker picture gallery below.) I heard another campus was decorated like the movie “Tron.” These people go hog-wild with theming that gives Disney a run for their money – a dragon spewing real smoke, a zen garden, fish pond with walking bridge, a giant Chinese takeout box with slide, decorated entrances and a massive kung foo panda sitting on top of the building. To complete the movie experience you can pick up a box of popcorn and soda as you take your seat.

I always bring earplugs with me when I visit churches but I forgot mine this trip. Thankfully, Lifechurch provides earplugs on request. It’s seriously the loudest church I’ve ever been to – ridiculously so (I wish I had thought to use my db meter app but it had to be approaching 110 dbs.) If I didn’t have the earplugs I simply could not have stayed, it was so excruciatingly loud.

Once the earplugs reduced the noise to normal, non-damage inducing levels, I enjoyed it. The music was perfect as you would expect in a megachurch of this stature – a perfect band, winsome young worship leader and a pretty female backup vocalist. They opened with a cover of Kings of Leon’s Use Somebody then launched into a praise set of a few tunes. I appreciated hearing songs I knew like Beautiful Jesus and Inside Out.

Now this is, of course, entirely subjective but I didn’t really feel a worship vibe going on. I attended Crosspointe Church in Norman that morning, and while it was nowhere near as polished as Lifechurch I was immediately surprised by the presence of God I sensed in the congregation.

From what I understand about churches like Lifechurch, worship is a distant second in the scheme of things and only meant as a prelude to the pinnacle of the service: the sermon. In fact, a worship leader of one mega church with a similar format to Lifechurch told me their unsaved visitors complained about “too much worship music” so they cut their sets short!

Lifechurch and their video venues run on tight time constraints. All services broadcast the live sermon simultaneously and each campus band has to end at the same time. I would guess all songs are on a strict click track with no option to repeat a chorus or pause for prayer. Maybe if you don’t make room for the Spirit to show up He won’t?

While the music was excellent but not particularly (for me) emotionally moving, the sermon was one of the most spectacular displays of melding media, emotion and truth that I’ve ever experienced. The last time I felt this way about a sermon was five years ago… at my last trip to Lifechurch. Imagine visiting a church and begin blown away by a sermon, then getting blown away again on a random visit five years later! Craig Groeschel is the real, consistent deal and is one of my favorite preachers.

What made the experience wonderful was the seamless blend of the film “Signs” with Craig’s message. A clip of the movie played, then effortlessly blended into Craig’s sermon. The camera work and transitions were so expertly done you couldn’t tell where the movie ended and the sermon began. Even the movie score was perfectly transitioned. Then, at the climax of the movie as the orchestra swelled, Craig explained how God can use signs and circumstances to guide us. It touched me to my core and brought me to tears – I’ll remember it for years just as I can remember Craig’s sermon from my visit five years ago.

This is how it’s done – technical excellence in media balanced with excellence in Biblical truth. Church media people – you might want to book a flight and experience this for yourselves during one of their “At the Movies” summer series.

Photos from LifeChurch:

worshipideas:

Essential reading for worship leaders since 2002.

 

Get the latest worship news, ideas and a list

of the top CCLI songs delivered every Tuesday... for FREE!